Table of Contents

Posted 01/09/2026

The Silent Inflation: Anatomy of the Rising Cost of American Homeownership (2000–2025)

Is your home an asset or a liability? The "Silent Inflation" of property taxes, insurance, and maintenance now costs homeowners over $21k annually. See the full breakdown here.

Hero image

Executive Summary

The American housing market is frequently analyzed through the lens of asset appreciation  —  the headline-grabbing rise in listing prices that has defined the post-pandemic economy. 

However, a parallel and arguably more acute financial reality has unfolded for the residential occupant: homeownership costs. The "Three Levers" of homeownership costs are: 

  1. Mortgage Interest

  2. Homeowners Insurance

  3. Property Taxes

Our analysis reveals that while home values have surged, the ongoing costs of maintaining property ownershiphave risen at a rate that frequently outpaces both the Consumer Price Index (CPI) and wage growth. 

This divergence creates a "silent inflation" where the monthly ledger of homeownership expands relentlessly, often independent of the homeowner's equity position. 

We observe a structural shift:

  • (2010-2020): Low-rate, stable-cost environment 

  • (2022–2025): A high-rate, volatile-cost environment

Global capital markets, climate risk modeling, and municipal budgetary pressures primarily drive this shift.

In our research, we’ve adjusted historical data for inflation and isolated the specific drivers of each lever. This provides a nuanced understanding of why the "monthly nut" of homeownership has become the defining economic challenge of our time. 

The findings indicate that hidden costs of homeownership (taxes, insurance, and maintenance) now average between $15,979 and $21,400 annually for a typical single-family home, essentially amounting to a second mortgage in many jurisdictions.1


Part I: The Macroeconomic Context

The Divergence of Shelter Costs and General Inflation

To understand the specific pressures on the American homeowner, one must first distinguish between "headline inflation" and "shelter inflation." The Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) tracks the Consumer Price Index (CPI), a basket of goods and services intended to represent the cost of living. 

From 2020 to 2024, the cumulative inflation rate for the U.S. economy was approximately 25%.3 Although this historically high figure signals a significant loss of purchasing power, it doesn't reflect the extreme volatility in specific homeownership sectors.

The cost of owning a home is not a monolithic figure; it is a composite of three distinct markets, each responding to different economic stimuli:

  1. Mortgages often react to Federal Reserve policy and the bond market.

  2. Insurance responds to global reinsurance markets, climate models, and construction material costs.

  3. Property Taxes respond to local municipal budgets and retrospective property assessments.

When these Three Levers pull in the same direction, upward, as they have since 2022, the compounding effect on the homeowner is severe. 

For example, while the general price of consumer goods stabilized somewhat in 2024, the cost of home maintenance (labor and materials) continued to rise, averaging $8,808 annually.1 Similarly, homeowners' insurance premiums in 2024 rose twice as fast as the general inflation rate.4

This decoupling of housing costs from general inflation creates a "wealth illusion." Here’s an example of what many are experiencing: 1. A homeowner may see their Zestimate or appraisal value skyrocket, suggesting increased wealth. 

2. Yet, their disposable income is simultaneously squeezed by rising insurance premiums and tax bills that are pegged to that very same rising value. 

3. The asset creates wealth on paper but consumes cash flow in reality, leaving many "house rich and cash poor."

How much are you overpaying?

Hundreds...thousands?

The Historical Baseline (2000-2020)

The last quarter-century offers a tale of two markets. The subprime boom and subsequent bust defined the first decade of the twenty-first century.

  • Mortgage rates hovered between 5% and 8%.5 Following the Great Recession, the U.S. entered an abnormal period of "easy money."

  • From 2011 to 2021, mortgage rates plummeted, bottoming out at 2.96% in 2021.5 Simultaneously, inflation remained benign, often below the Fed's 2% target.

This era masked the underlying structural increases in taxes and insurance. Because the cost of debt (the mortgage) was so cheap, buyers could absorb creeping tax and insurance hikes without breaking their monthly budgets. 

When the Federal Reserve aggressively hiked rates in 2022 and 2023 to combat post-COVID inflation, it ripped away the financial mask. Homeowners were suddenly exposed to the raw cost of all Three Levers simultaneously, leading to the affordability crisis we observe today.


Part II: The Mortgage Lever

The mortgage principal and interest payment is the "anchor" of homeownership costs. It is typically the most significant single expense and, for those with fixed-rate loans, the only one that remains theoretically static. 

However, for new buyers entering the market or existing owners looking to move, the mortgage lever has undergone a most dramatic shift in forty years.

The End of the "Free Money" Era

The collapse of mortgage rates during the pandemic — reaching a low of 2.65% in early 2021 — fueled a buying frenzy. This was not merely a market fluctuation; it was a historic aberration. 

To contextualize, the average 30-year fixed rate in the year 2000 was 8.05%.5 

In the 1980s, it peaked above 16%. The sub-3% rates of 2020 and 2021 allowed buyers to purchase significantly more expensive homes while keeping monthly payments low.

The reversal was violent. 

By October 2023, rates surged to nearly 8% before settling into the 6% range by late 2025.6 

The way this change in interest rates works is a big deal, and many homeowners don’t fully grasp it. It doesn't affect how affordable a home is in a simple, one-to-one way. Instead, because loan payments are calculated over time (amortization), a slight change in the rate can have a much larger, disproportionate impact on the monthly payment.

Consider the three-to-four-year difference for a standard $400,000 mortgage 

Dates & Rates

Monthly Principal and Interest Payment

Total 30-year Interest

2021 (3.0%)

$1,686 

$207,000

2024/5 (6.8%)

$2,608 (+55%)

$538,000 (+160%)

For the same loan amount, the monthly obligation rises by nearly $1,000 — a 55% increase. This effectively devalues the purchasing power of the American buyer. To maintain the same $1,686 monthly payment in a 6.8% rate environment, a buyer would need to reduce their loan amount to roughly $258,000. Yet, home prices did not drop by 35% to compensate; in fact, they continued to rise, reaching a median sales price of over $420,000 by 2025.7

The Payment-to-Income Dislocation

The standard affordability metric is the ratio of the mortgage payment to household income. Historically, a healthy ratio is under 28%. From 1984 to 2021, mortgage payments accounted for less than 20% of median household income in all but five years.8 This stability allowed for other forms of consumption and savings.

However, the convergence of high prices and high rates shattered this norm. 

  • In 2022, the mortgage payment on a median-priced home accounted for roughly 31% of median household income.

  • By 2023, that share rose to nearly 34%.8 This is the highest burden recorded in decades, surpassing the peaks of the mid-2000s housing bubble.

To afford a median-priced home in the U.S. in 2025, a household requires an annual income of nearly $117,000.8 

Given that the median household income is approximately $83,730 9, a mathematical chasm has opened. The "average" family can no longer afford the "average" home without becoming "house poor," allocating a dangerous percentage of their gross income to the mortgage lever alone.

Inflation-Adjusted Reality Check: 1980s vs. 2020s

A common counter-argument to the current affordability crisis is the comparison to the early 1980s, when mortgage rates topped 18%. Critics argue that today's 6-7% rates are historically moderate. However, this ignores the relationship between income, home prices, and interest rates.

Metric

1981 and 1985

2024 and 2025

Typical Monthly Mortgage Payment (Nominal)

$771 (1981)8

~$2,650 (2024 adjusted for inflation)

Median Home Price to Median Income Ratio

3.5x (1985)

5.1x (2025)10

Furthermore, the trajectory of costs is alarming. 

In 2020, the typical monthly mortgage payment was roughly $1,100. By 2024, it had doubled to $2,207.8 

Even when adjusting the 2020 payment for inflation (which would bring it to roughly $1,400 in 2024 dollars), the real cost increase to the homeowner is nearly $800 per month.8 

This confirms that the current crisis is not merely a nominal illusion of inflation; it is a fundamental increase in the real cost of shelter capital.

The Current "Lock-In" Effect

The sharp rise in the mortgage lever has created a secondary cost: market paralysis. 

Millions of homeowners currently hold mortgages with rates below 4%. Refinancing or selling to buy a new home would mean trading a 3% rate for a 6%+ rate, triggering a massive increase in monthly payments for no improvement in housing quality.

This "lock-in" effect restricts housing supply. With fewer existing homes hitting the market, inventory remains tight, paradoxically keeping home prices high despite high interest rates.11 

New buyers are thus squeezed from both sides:

  1. They face high borrowing costs (the rate)

  2. The asset costs (the price) because the owners of the existing stock cannot afford to sell. 

This stagnation is a hidden tax on the economy, reducing labor mobility and forcing growing families to remain in unsuitable housing.

The Mortgage Burden Shift (2020 vs. 2024)

Metric

2020

2024/2025

% Change

Median Home Price

~$329,000

~$426,800

+29.7%

30-Year Fixed Rate

~3.1%

~6.2% to 6.8%

+100% - 119%

Monthly P&I Payment

~$1,100

~$2,207

+100%

Payment as % of Income

<20%

~34%

+70%

Req. Income for Median Home

~$60,000

~$117,000

+95%

Sources: Bankrate 8, Visual Capitalist 10, Fred St. Louis.6


Part III: The Second Lever  —  Insurance

If the mortgage lever is the heavy anchor, the insurance lever is the volatile storm tossing the ship. Historically, homeowners insurance (HOI) was a boring, predictable utility — a minor line item in the escrow account that rose gently with inflation. 

In the 2020s, however, insurance has mutated into a chaotic variable, capable of doubling or tripling in cost over short periods, or vanishing entirely.

Pricing the Unpriceable is Challenging

The U.S. insurance market is currently in a "hard market" cycle, characterized by high premiums and strict underwriting standards. 

Unlike the mortgage market, which is driven by financial policy, the insurance market is driven by physical reality — specifically, the cost of repairing homes and the frequency of home destruction.

Between 2019 and 2023, homeowners' insurance premiums nationwide rose by an average of 38%.12 More granular data from the Consumer Federation of America indicates a 24% increase from 2021 to 2024 alone, a rate double that of general inflation.4 

By 2024/2025, the average annual premium for a standard policy had reached between $2,110 and $2,424, depending on the data provider.13

However, insurance averages are misleading. 

They flatten the extreme spikes seen in "catastrophe-exposed" regions into the stable rates of the Midwest and Northeast, obscuring the true crisis. In high-risk states like Florida and California, the insurance burden has become a monthly expense rivaling property taxes. 

To manage these fluctuations, many homeowners are turning to insurance rate monitoring services to ensure they aren't overpaying in this volatile market.

The Three Drivers of Insurance Inflation

To understand why your premium is rising, you must look at the three components of the insurer's balance sheet:

1. Replacement Cost Inflation

Insurance covers the cost to rebuild, not the market value. A home might sell for less in a downturn, but if the price of lumber, copper, and skilled labor rises, the insurance premium must increase. 

Following the pandemic, residential construction costs surged. How?

  1. The Producer Price Index (PPI) for construction inputs jumped over 40% cumulatively from 2020 to 2023.15

  2. Even as supply chains normalized in 2024, the baseline labor cost remained elevated. Insurers responded by increasing the "Coverage A" (dwelling coverage) limits on policies, automatically driving up premiums.16

2. Reinsurance Rates

Primary insurers (like State Farm or Allstate) buy their own insurance to protect against solvency-threatening events (like a Category 5 hurricane). This is called reinsurance. The cost of reinsurance has exploded! 

The Global Property Catastrophe Rate-on-Line Index, which tracks these costs, rose 60% from 2017 to 2024.17 In 2023 alone, reinsurance rates spiked nearly 30% before moderating slightly in 2024.17 

Primary carriers often have no choice but to pass these costs directly to the consumer. This is why a homeowner in a landlocked state might still see a rate increase; they are partly subsidizing the global cost of risk capital.

3. "Secondary Perils" and Frequency

While headlines focus on hurricanes, the insurance industry is bleeding cash from "secondary perils,” which are severe convective storms (thunderstorms), hail, and wildfires. 

In 2023, the industry's net combined ratio was 110.9, meaning for every $100 collected in premiums, insurers paid out $110.90 in claims and expenses.18 This unprofitability is unsustainable. 

Thus, insurers are correcting for a decade of underpricing climate risk, leading to sharp, sudden premium changes.

The Crisis of Availability: The "Retreat"

The most disturbing trend in the home insurance market is not the price of coverage, but the absence of it. 

Major carriers are engaging in a strategic retreat from high-risk markets, leaving homeowners vulnerable.

California: 

In response to escalating wildfire risks and regulatory caps on rate increases, seven of the top twelve insurers — including State Farm and Allstate — paused or restricted new business in 2023 and 2024.19 

Non-renewal rates in wildfire zones have quadrupled since 2018.20 This forces homeowners onto the "FAIR Plan," a state-run pool of last resort that offers limited coverage at significantly higher prices.

Florida: 

The Sunshine State represents the epicenter of the crisis. Many national carriers have fled, leaving the market to a patchwork of small, capitalization-light local insurers and the state-backed Citizens Property Insurance Corporation. 

Citizens is now the largest insurer in Florida, holding nearly 690,000 policies.21 This concentrates risk on the state's taxpayers. If a massive storm hits and Citizens' reserves are exhausted, the state can levy assessments (taxes) on all insurance policyholders in Florida to cover the gap.

Texas: 

The Lone Star State faces what analysts call a "triple-threat" crisis: being simultaneously vulnerable to hurricanes, hailstorms, and wildfires. 

In 2023, Texas experienced $28 billion in weather-related claims, with Progressive reporting that 40% of its recent storm losses occurred there.28 

The situation deteriorated sharply in 2024, with at least four companies exiting Texas entirely, affecting approximately 11,000 policyholders.29

  • Major carriers, including Farmers Insurance, announced substantial reductions in new policies in 2023.

  • Foremost Insurance ceased writing and renewing policies entirely just weeks before Hurricane Beryl struck in 2024, causing an estimated $2.5 to $4.5 billion in insured losses.30

  • Progressive became the latest major insurer to temporarily restrict new homeowner business in certain parts of Texas, citing "weather-related volatility."31

The Texas Windstorm Insurance Association (TWIA), which covers wind and hail in coastal areas, has experienced an even more dramatic reversal. TWIA began 2024 with a $46 million surplus but started 2025 with a $413.5 million deficit after Hurricane Beryl depleted its reserves.32

Combined, these state-backed pools are projected to hold nearly 285,000 policies by late 2025, more than at any point in Texas history.

The Geographic Lottery: State-by-State Disparities

The divergence in insurance costs creates a forked housing market. In low-risk states, insurance remains a manageable utility. In high-risk states, it’s like a second mortgage.

  • Extreme Examples: Florida homeowners pay an average of nearly $6,000 annually, with many paying over $9,000 in coastal zones.13 Oklahoma, located in the heart of Tornado Alley, sees premiums averaging between $4,695 and $6,210.13

  • Safe Haven Examples: In contrast, homeowners in Vermont, New Hampshire, and Delaware pay average annual premiums below $1,100.13

This disparity distorts real estate values. A home in Oklahoma carries a "holding cost penalty" compared to a similarly priced home in Ohio. Over a 30-year ownership period, the Oklahoma homeowner might pay an additional $100,000 to $150,000 in insurance premiums compared to their Ohio counterpart, significantly eroding the net return on the asset.

The Geography of Risk: Insurance Costs by State (2024/2025)

State

Avg. Annual Premium

Monthly Cost

3-Year Trend

Primary Risk Drivers

Florida

$5,838-$9,462

$486-$789

Extreme Increase

Hurricanes, Litigation, Reinsuranc

Oklahoma

$4,695-$6,210

$391-$518

High Increase

Hail, Tornadoes, Convective Storms

Texas

$3,899-$4,585

$325-$382

High Increase

Hail, Hurricanes, Winter Freezes

Nebraska

$4,505-$6,587

$375-$549

High Increase

Wind/Hail Damage

California

$1,641-$2,211

$137-$184

Availability Crisis

Wildfire, Regulatory Friction

New Jersey

$1,214-$1,509

$101-$125

Moderate

Coastal Storms (offset by density)

Vermont

$827-$950

$69-$79

Stable

Low Catastrophe Exposure

Sources: Bankrate 13, NerdWallet 14, Consumer Federation of America.22 (Note: Ranges reflect differences in methodology between data providers).

The Multifamily Parallel

It is worth noting that this trend is not limited to single-family homes. 

The Federal Reserve reports that insurance costs for multifamily apartment buildings rose 76% from 2019 to 2024.23 

This is a critical context for the residential market because landlords pass these costs down to renters. Thus, the insurance lever is driving up the cost of shelter for all Americans, not just homeowners, fueling broader inflation.


Part IV: The Third Lever  —  Property Taxes

Property taxes are the "silent partner" in homeownership. Unlike the mortgage — which is a contract with a bank, or insurance, which is a contract for protection — property taxes are a statutory obligation to the government. 

They are the primary revenue engine for local municipalities, funding schools, police, fire departments, and infrastructure.

The defining characteristic of the property tax lever in the 2020s is the Assessment Lag.

The Mechanism of the Lag

Property taxes are calculated based on the assessed value of a home. Depending on the jurisdiction, a home may be reassessed annually, every two years, or even every three to five years. For more on how this process works, see our guide on what tax assessment means.

However, assessments rarely occur in real time. Depending on the local jurisdiction, a home may be reassessed annually, every two years, or even every three to five years (on a rotating basis). This assessment lag occurred throughout Texas in 2025.

The massive surge in home values that occurred from 2020 to 2022 — where prices rose nearly 40% nationally — did not immediately appear on tax bills. It takes time for municipal assessors to capture that data and adjust the tax rolls. We are currently in the "catch-up" phase.

From 2019 to 2023, property tax revenue saw the largest total increase among major tax categories, rising by $165 billion (27%) to $782 billion.24

Homeowners who purchased in 2020 or 2021 often calculated their monthly budgets based on the previous owner's tax bills. As assessments catch up to the new market reality, these homeowners are experiencing "bill shock," with tax obligations jumping significantly years after the purchase.

Property tax appeals are becoming increasingly vital for homeowners to ensure their assessments remain fair.

The Inflation of Governance

A critical, often overlooked factor is that property taxes are not just a function of home values; they are a function of municipal spending. 

Local governments are major consumers of labor and materials. They pay:

  • Teacher salaries

  • Pave roads

  • Parks

  • Emergency services

Inflation has driven up the cost of providing these services. If the costs of asphalt, fuel, and municipal wages rise by 25% (matching the broader CPI), the local government must raise more revenue to maintain the same level of service. 

Therefore, even if home prices were to stabilize or drop, property taxes would likely continue to rise to cover the inflated cost of governance. This makes the tax lever a "ratchet”; it turns easily upward but rarely reverses.

The Commercial Real Estate Contagion

A looming threat to residential property taxes is the slow-motion collapse of the commercial office sector. In many cities, office buildings serve as a massive tax base. With remote work driving up vacancy rates, the value of commercial office towers has plummeted.

Municipalities must balance their budgets. If commercial tax revenue falls due to lower valuations, the tax burden must shift elsewhere to make up the difference. The most likely target is the residential sector, which has appreciated. 

We are beginning to see a "tax shift" in which homeowners are forced to shoulder a larger share of the municipal budget to subsidize losses in the commercial sector. This is occurring in Cook County, Illinois (home to Chicago), leading to an average increase of $700 per homeowner, totaling around $500 million.

In many areas, this structural shift could ensure that residential property taxes will face upward pressure for the remainder of the decade, independent of residential market dynamics.

Smart Investors Optimize Every Expense

Get your free savings estimate

State-by-State Disparities: The Effective Rate Spectrum

As with insurance, the burden of property taxes varies widely by geography. The "effective tax rate" is the annual tax bill divided by the home's value.

The High-Tax Corridors: 

  • The Northeast and Midwest impose the heaviest burdens. New Jersey consistently ranks highest, with an effective rate often exceeding 2.0%. In counties like Salem (NJ) and Monroe (NY), effective rates can top 2.3%.24

  • Illinois follows closely, with rates around 1.8% to 2.2%. In these states, property taxes act as a wealth tax, eroding equity accumulation. 

    • A homeowner in New Jersey, paying $12,000 annually in taxes, pays an additional $1,000 per month in mortgage payments compared to a low-tax state.

The Low-Tax Belts: 

  • States like Hawaii (0.32%) and Alabama (0.36%) have the lowest effective rates.24

    • However, this data requires context. Hawaii's low rate is applied to astronomical home values, meaning the actual dollar amount paid is still high.

    • Alabama, conversely, combines low rates with lower home values, resulting in genuine affordability — though often at the cost of lower funding for public services.

Homeowners in these regions should still explore exemptions, such as the Texas homestead exemption or similar programs in their respective states, to maximize savings.

How much are you overpaying?

Hundreds...thousands?

Property Tax Burdens – The "Hidden Rent" (2025 Data)

State

The Median Effective Tax Rate

Median Tax Bill

1. Connecticut

3.14%

$6,162

2. New Jersey

2.82%

$8,227

3. Pennsylvania

2.81%

$3,063

4. New York

2.39%

$5,938

5. Illinois

2.35%

$4,715

6. Vermont

2.11%

$3,843

7. New Hampshire

1.91%

$5,895

8. Ohio

1.80%

$2,396

9. Nebraska

1.75%

$3,071

10. Texas

1.67%

$3,971

11. Wisconsin

1.58%

$3,346

12. Maine

1.57%

$3,200

13. Iowa

1.54%

$2,508

14. Rhode Island

1.48%

$4,920

15. South Dakota

1.45%

$2,732

16. Kansas

1.43%

$2,595

17. Delaware

1.41%

$1,362

18. Alaska

1.37%

$3,874

19. Mississippi

1.31%

$854

20. North Dakota

1.30%

$2,659

21. Massachusetts

1.23%

$5,844

22. California

1.21%

$4,683

23. Missouri

1.20%

$1,606

24. Florida

1.14%

$2,953

25. Minnesota

1.11%

$3,182

26. Georgia

1.08%

$2,212

27. Michigan

1.07%

$1,795

28. Maryland

1.06%

$3,419

29. Kentucky

1.02%

$1,031

30. Indiana

0.99%

$1,691

31. Oklahoma

0.97%

$1,269

32. Louisiana

0.91%

$865

33. Virginia

0.89%

$2,608

34. Washington

0.88%

$4,284

35. New Mexico

0.86%

$1,192

36. Oregon

0.86%

$3,628

37. Arkansas

0.84%

$877

38. Montana

0.83%

$2,646

39. North Carolina

0.82%

$1,615

40. Nevada

0.80%

$1,782

41. District of Columbia

0.77%

$4,081

42. South Carolina

0.72%

$1,086

43. West Virginia

0.72%

$607

44. Wyoming

0.65%

$1,635

45. Tennessee

0.64%

$1,206

46. Arizona

0.56%

$1,666

47. Colorado

0.55%

$2,283

48. Utah

0.55%

$2,492

49. Idaho

0.50%

$1,894

50. Alabama

0.47%

$717

51. Hawaii

0.29%

$2,234

Sources: https://www.ownwell.com/trends and https://www.ownwell.com/blog/states-without-property-tax


Part V: The Convergence  —  The Total Cost of Ownership

When the Mortgage lever, the Insurance lever, and the Tax lever are pulled simultaneously, the result is a crisis of total cost of ownership (TCO). 

The compartmentalized view of these costs often hides the aggregate impact. When viewed together, they reveal why so many Americans feel "house poor" despite rising wages.

Quantifying the "Hidden Costs"

Two recent major studies have attempted to quantify the non-mortgage costs of homeownership (Taxes + Insurance + Maintenance).

  1. The Bankrate Analysis (2024/2025): This study takes a comprehensive view, including utilities (energy/internet) in the "holding cost" calculation. It estimates the average annual hidden cost of owning a single-family home at $21,400, a 26% increase from four years prior.25

  2. The Zillow/Thumbtack Analysis (2024): This study focuses strictly on the structural costs: Taxes, Insurance, and Maintenance. It estimates the national average at $15,979 annually.2

Even using the conservative Zillow figure, the typical U.S. homeowner must budget approximately $1,330 per month, in addition to their mortgage payment, just to keep the house running and compliant. 

If we add the Bankrate utility estimates, that figure rises to nearly $1,780 per month.

For a household earning the median U.S. income of roughly $83,730 (approx. $5,500 monthly take-home pay after taxes), these hidden costs alone consume nearly 30% of their net income.

This leaves very little room for the mortgage payment itself, let alone food, transportation, and savings.

The Regional Squeeze: Where the Levers Overlap

The interaction of these levers creates distinct "pain zones" across the U.S. map.

  • The Coastal Squeeze (High Tax + High Maintenance): In the New York metro area and Massachusetts, high property taxes converge with high labor and maintenance costs.

    • Zillow estimates hidden costs in the NYC metro area at over $24,300 annually.27 Here, the government and the tradesmen are the primary drivers of cost.

  • The Sun Belt Squeeze (High Insurance + High Energy): In Florida and Texas, the lack of state income tax is often touted as an economic benefit.

    • However, the combination of skyrocketing insurance premiums, high property taxes (specifically in Texas, where rates frequently exceed 1.5%), and high cooling costs creates a different kind of burden.

    • In Miami, hidden costs reach nearly $20,000 annually 27, primarily driven by the insurance crisis.

  • The Affordability Havens: The data points to a "Hold-Out Belt" in the interior South and Midwest. States like West Virginia, Mississippi, Indiana, and Arkansas consistently rank as the most affordable. 

    • In West Virginia, the combination of low property values, low taxes ($1,063 avg), and moderate insurance ($1,009 avg) keeps hidden costs around $12,500 annually — nearly half that of coastal markets.26

    • This disparity is driving a quiet migration of remote workers and retirees seeking relief from the "Three Levers."

The Total Cost Hierarchy (2024 Estimates)

State/Metro

Annual "Hidden Costs"

Dominant Lever(s)

Hawaii

$34,573

Maintenance (Labor/Shipping) & Energy

California

$32,262

Maintenance & Insurance Availability

New Jersey

$29,751

Property Taxes (Extreme)

New York (Metro)

$24,381

Taxes & Maintenance

Florida

$24,713 (State avg varies)

Insurance & Energy

Texas

~$20,000 (City dependent)

Taxes & Insurance

Indiana

$14,903

Balanced/Low Costs

West Virginia

$12,579

Low Taxes & Values

Sources: Bankrate 26, Zillow.27

The Maintenance Multiplier

A critical component of these calculations is maintenance. Both Bankrate and Zillow utilize data suggesting homeowners should budget roughly 2% of the home's value annually for repairs. Because home values spiked ~40% post-pandemic, the nominal maintenance budget has ballooned purely as a function of math.

However, real costs have also risen. 

The "Maintenance Multiplier" effect occurs because the inputs for repair — copper pipe, lumber, asphalt shingles, and skilled labor — have experienced inflation rates far higher than the CPI. 

The price of asphalt shingles, for instance, tracks with oil prices, while skilled labor shortages have driven up plumbers’ and electricians’ hourly rates. Thus, homeowners are hit twice: they have a more expensive asset to maintain, and the per-unit cost of maintenance has risen.


Part VI: Conclusion and Future Outlook

The narrative of American homeownership has fundamentally changed. For decades, the primary barrier to entry was the down payment. Once most Americans cleared that hurdle, the ongoing costs were viewed as stable and manageable: a "forced savings" account that built wealth over time.

Today, the "Three Levers" have transformed the home from a passive asset into an active liability. 

The convergence of 6-7% mortgage rates, insurance premiums rising at double-digit clips, and property taxes catching up to inflated valuations has created a high-friction environment.

The "Insurance-First" Market

Looking ahead to 2026 and beyond, we are entering an "Insurance-First" housing market in climate-exposed regions.

 In states like Florida and California, a property's insurability will likely determine its value more than its granite countertops or school district. 

We may see property devaluation in areas where private insurance is unavailable, as the cost of state-backed "last resort" policies erodes buyers' purchasing power.

The New Normal for Rates

While markets are pricing in rate cuts, the structural factors keeping rates elevated — federal deficits, sticky inflation, and global capital competition — suggest that sub-3% mortgage rates of 2021 will not return in the foreseeable future. 

The "New Normal" for the mortgage lever is likely in the 5.5% to 6.5% range. Homeowners and buyers must recalibrate their expectations and budgets to account for the higher cost of capital.

The Property Tax Ratchet Continues

Finally, property taxes will likely continue to outpace inflation for the remainder of the decade. 

As commercial real estate values reset lower, shifting the tax burden to residential owners, and as municipal labor and infrastructure costs rise, the tax lever will continue to exert upward pressure on monthly payments.

For the homeowners and single-family investors, this reality underscores the importance of actively managing homeownership costs. It’s now necessary to:

  1. Appeal property tax assessments

  2. Shop aggressively for insurance (and mitigating risks to lower premiums)

  3. Refinance mortgages opportunistically 

These are no longer optional financial optimizations; they are defensive necessities in an era of rising holding costs. The American Dream is still attainable, but the price of admission (and the price of retention) has irrevocably risen.

Want to try what made Ownwell famous?

Save on your property taxes in 3 minutes or less


Works cited

  1. Hidden Costs of Homeownership Press Release - Bankrate, accessed December 22, 2025, https://www.bankrate.com/f/102997/x/ce71debe80/hidden-costs-of-homeownership-press-release-1.pdf

  2. The Hidden Costs of Homeownership Top $16,000 a Year - Zillow Research, accessed December 22, 2025, https://www.zillow.com/research/hidden-costs-homeownership-35716/

  3. Hidden Homeownership Costs Hit $21,000 A Year In 2025 | Bankrate, accessed December 22, 2025, https://www.bankrate.com/home-equity/hidden-costs-of-homeownership-study/

  4. New Report Finds American Homeowners Faced 24% Increase in Homeowners Insurance Premiums, Consumer Federation of America, accessed December 22, 2025, https://consumerfed.org/press_release/new-report-finds-american-homeowners-faced-24-increase-in-homeowners-insurance-premiums-over-the-past-three-years/

  5. Historical mortgage rates: 1971 to 2025, accessed December 22, 2025, https://www.rocketmortgage.com/learn/historical-mortgage-rates-30-year-fixed

  6. Mortgage Rates - Freddie Mac, accessed December 22, 2025, https://www.freddiemac.com/pmms

  7. Median Sales Price of Houses Sold for the United States (MSPUS) | FRED | St. Louis Fed, accessed December 22, 2025, https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MSPUS

  8. Monthly Mortgage Payments: 1970s to 2025 | Bankrate, accessed December 22, 2025, https://www.bankrate.com/mortgages/monthly-mortgage-payments-history/

  9. Median Household Income in the United States (MEHOINUSA646N) | FRED | St. Louis Fed, accessed December 22, 2025, https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MEHOINUSA646N

  10. Charted: American Income vs. Home Prices (1985–2025) - Visual Capitalist, accessed December 22, 2025, https://www.visualcapitalist.com/charted-american-income-vs-home-prices-1985-2025/

  11. Zillow Home Value and Home Sales Forecast (November 2025) - Zillow Research, accessed December 22, 2025, https://www.zillow.com/research/home-value-sales-forecast-33822/

  12. Financial Inclusion and Barriers to Insurance: An Overview and Preliminary Findings - NAIC, accessed December 22, 2025, https://content.naic.org/sites/default/files/inline-files/Insurance%20Affordability%20Summer%202024%20National%20Meeting_Aug%202nd%20%282%29_0.pdf

  13. Average homeowners insurance cost in December 2025 | Bankrate, accessed December 22, 2025, https://www.bankrate.com/insurance/homeowners-insurance/homeowners-insurance-cost/

  14. How Much Is Homeowners Insurance? Average 2025 Rates - NerdWallet, accessed December 22, 2025, https://www.nerdwallet.com/insurance/homeowners/learn/average-homeowners-insurance-cost

  15. Construction Inflation 2024, accessed December 22, 2025, https://edzarenski.com/2024/01/17/construction-inflation-2024/

  16. Report: Home Insurance Premiums Continue To Surge As Regulators Navigate Impact of Volatile Market - Matic, accessed December 22, 2025, https://matic.com/blog/mid-year-home-insurance-trends-2024/

  17. Guy Carpenter Global Property Catastrophe Rate-On-Line Index - Artemis.bm, accessed December 22, 2025, https://www.artemis.bm/global-property-cat-rate-on-line-index/

  18. Trends and Insights: Homeowners Insurance Rates, accessed December 22, 2025, https://www.iii.org/sites/default/files/docs/pdf/triple-i_trends_and_insights_homeowners_insurance_rates_07092024.pdf

  19. Limited Home Insurance Options in California As Major Carriers Pull Back | Bankrate, accessed December 22, 2025, https://www.bankrate.com/insurance/homeowners-insurance/carriers-exit-california-home-insurance/

  20. Homeowners in Florida and California Dropped by Their Insurance Companies at Highest Rate in Nation - Weiss Ratings, accessed December 22, 2025, https://weissratings.com/en/weiss-news/homeowners-in-florida-and-california-dropped-by-their-insurance-companies-at-highest-rate-in-nation

  21. Top 25 Largest Florida Homeowners Insurance Companies | 2024 Ranking, accessed December 22, 2025, https://www.weshopinsurance.com/news/2025/05/top-25-largest-florida-homeowners-insurance-companies-2024-ranking

  22. Overburdened: The Dramatic Increase in Homeowners Insurance Premiums and its Impacts on American Homeowners - Consumer Federation of America, accessed December 22, 2025, https://consumerfed.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/03/OverburdenedReport.pdf

  23. The Fed - Rising Property Insurance Costs and Pass-Through to Rents for Apartment Buildings - Federal Reserve Board, accessed December 22, 2025, https://www.federalreserve.gov/econres/notes/feds-notes/rising-property-insurance-costs-and-pass-through-to-rents-for-apartment-buildings-20250919.html

  24. Average Property Taxes in the U.S. by State, County, & City - Construction Coverage, accessed December 22, 2025, https://constructioncoverage.com/research/average-property-tax-by-state-county-city

  25. Hidden Costs of Homeownership Average $21400 Annually, Bankrate Reports, accessed December 22, 2025, https://newslink.mba.org/mba-newslinks/2025/june/mba-newslink-monday-june-23-2025/hidden-costs-of-homeownership-average-21400-annually-bankrate-reports/

  26. Hidden Costs of Homeownership Average $21,400 Annually Nationwide, Nearly Twice the Cost of the Lowest Cost State - Bankrate, accessed December 22, 2025, https://www.bankrate.com/f/102997/x/a6a85bbbeb/hidden-costs-of-homeownership-press-release-final-1.pdf

  27. Hidden costs of homeownership reach $16K per year - PR Newswire, accessed December 22, 2025, https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/hidden-costs-of-homeownership-reach-16k-per-year-302614207.html

  28. Why Are Insurance Companies Leaving Texas? 2025 Crisis Explained, Dick Law Firm, accessed January 7, 2026, https://www.dicklawfirm.com/blog/2025/september/why-are-insurers-leaving-texas-/

  29. What homeowners should do now after Progressive leaves Texas, KVUE, accessed January 7, 2026, https://www.kvue.com/article/news/local/progressive-coverage-issues-texas-rising-weather-related-damage-reaction-from-homeowners/269-bf00c910-35e6-4926-ab86-a6027e83fb7d

  30. Texas Homeowners Insurance Crisis | Bankrate, accessed January 7, 2026, https://www.bankrate.com/insurance/homeowners-insurance/texas-home-insurance-crisis/

  31. Texas Home Insurance Problem Worsens As Insurer Halts New Policies - Newsweek, accessed January 7, 2026, https://www.newsweek.com/texas-home-insurance-worsens-insurer-halts-new-policies-1949731

  32. Texas home insurance crisis: What homeowners need to know | Insurance.com, accessed January 7, 2026, https://www.insurance.com/home-and-renters-insurance/texas-home-insurance-rates-rising-fast

Success Stories

Real people, real properties, saving real money.

Loading spinner